The celebration of Chhath Mahaparv by thousands of Hindu devotees at Lewisville Lake in Texas has triggered a social media debate over religious freedom, environmental responsibility and the place of Indian cultural traditions in American public spaces.
The Bihar Jharkhand and Uttar Pradesh Society of America (BiJUSA) organized the two-day celebration on Nov. 15 and 16 at Stewart Creek Park in The Colony, near Lewisville Lake. The gathering featured traditional Chhath rituals, including prayers to the setting and rising sun, fasting and offerings of fruits and other items associated with the Hindu festival.
READ: Raja Krishnamoorthi condemns Bo French’s UT remarks (September 14, 2026)
The organizers describe the gathering as one of North America’s largest Chhath celebrations, bringing together thousands of devotees to observe a festival rooted in the traditions of Bihar, Jharkhand and Uttar Pradesh.
Bo French questions the celebration
The event drew criticism after videos and photographs circulated on X showing devotees entering the lake with baskets of fruits and performing religious rituals in the water.
Bo French, a Texas Republican political figure, questioned the celebrations in a post on X, writing: “This is not assimilation. Why are we allowing this?” Other social media users raised environmental concerns, alleging that religious offerings and substances poured into the lake could contaminate the water and threaten aquatic life.
One widely circulated post claimed that Indian religious practices were introducing toxic substances, including lead and mercury, into waterways. However, the post’s allegations about toxic contamination were not accompanied by independently verified environmental test results.
Organizers and supporters defend the rituals
Supporters of the gathering countered that the event was held at a designated public recreational facility and that the offerings traditionally used during Chhath include fruits, bamboo baskets and other natural materials.
Some social media users also pointed to the need to distinguish between biodegradable offerings and materials that could potentially cause environmental damage.
A post by social media user Chad Felix Greene said the annual gathering took place under the oversight of The Colony Parks and Recreation Department, with the park rented for the occasion. He also claimed that sanitation and cleanup were monitored and that participants took their offerings back with them.
What does the environmental record show?
The controversy has also raised questions about the environmental impact of religious gatherings at public water bodies. The Texas Commission on Environmental Quality’s 2026 Integrated Report includes Lewisville Lake as a monitored water body, identifying the Stewart Creek arm among its assessment areas. The report provides a framework for evaluating water quality and aquatic life but does not establish that the Chhath celebrations caused pollution or contamination.
Environmental concerns about religious offerings and waste disposal can be examined separately from criticism of the religious practices themselves. Ensuring that food, packaging and other materials are collected and disposed of responsibly remains important for public events held near lakes and rivers.
A wider debate over immigrant traditions
The controversy has reopened a broader discussion about how immigrant communities preserve their religious and cultural identities in the United States.
For Indian Americans, public celebrations of festivals such as Diwali, Holi and Chhath are important expressions of cultural continuity, particularly for younger generations growing up outside India.
Chhath Puja, observed primarily by communities with roots in Bihar, Jharkhand and eastern Uttar Pradesh, is among the most demanding Hindu festivals. Devotees observe an extended fast and offer prayers to the setting and rising sun while standing in rivers, ponds or other water bodies. The festival’s central rituals involve offerings of fruits, sugarcane and traditional food items, often arranged in bamboo baskets. Unlike festivals centered on idol immersion, Chhath’s principal observance is the offering of arghya to the Sun God.
READ: ‘Make College Football Great Again’: Education Dept. ‘racist’ post linked to Bo French controversy draws backlash (September 21, 2026)
The debate in Texas therefore involves two distinct questions: how public spaces can accommodate religious and cultural gatherings while protecting the environment, and how immigrant communities can practice their traditions without facing blanket judgments about their assimilation.
The discussion has also highlighted the importance of applying environmental standards consistently to all public gatherings, irrespective of the cultural or religious backgrounds of their participants.


