India’s economic reform agenda under Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s third government faces a significant implementation challenge. 26 of the 30 recommendations in the India Reforms Scorecard 3.0 yet to begin, according to Aryan D’Rozario, Associate Fellow at the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS) in Washington, D.C.
D’Rozario, who is associated with CSIS’s Chair on India and Emerging Asia Economics, said the government had completed three reforms, including rationalizing Goods and Services Tax (GST) slabs. It also opened the nuclear energy sector to private investment through the SHANTI Act, and introduced Jan Vishwas. 2.0.
However, major structural changes involving land acquisition, agricultural laws, labor flexibility, privatization and foreign direct investment (FDI) liberalization remain pending, he told The American Bazaar via email.
The assessment comes as India enters the midpoint of Modi’s third five-year term, which began in June 2024. A CSIS analysis, “Assessing Modi 3.0 Reforms at the Midway Point,” by Richard M. Rossow, Chair on India and Emerging Asia Economics and Senior Adviser at CSIS, also described the government’s reform record as mixed.
While the CSIS analysis identified trade policy and selected domestic reforms as areas of progress, it called for renewed attention to FDI liberalization and improvements in state-level business environments.
READ: Jeffrey Sachs predicts India will become world’s largest economy by 2100 (November 3, 2026)
D’Rozario said the priorities of the Modi government’s three terms had evolved from opening the economy to improving business conditions, competitiveness and employment generation.
“Each Scorecard represents one term of Prime Minister Modi’s government. In each term, some priorities remain the same while others change. Scorecard 1.0 (2014–19) came with a vision to open the economy: FDI caps, deregulating fuel prices, GST, etc. Scorecard 2.0 (2019–24) moved toward privatization, the financial sector, and the courts.
Scorecard 3.0 is about making it easier and cheaper to do business: GST compliance, single-window clearances, trade facilitation, and the core factors of land, labor and agriculture. So yes, the priorities have shifted from fixing how the economy works to growth and jobs. Market-opening items haven’t disappeared, though. FDI in multi-brand retail and e-commerce is on all three lists, which shows how hard they have been to move – but also how important they are to expand India’s economy.”
The first edition of the Scorecard covered the 2014-19 period, when reforms included changes to foreign investment limits, fuel pricing and the introduction of GST. The second edition, covering 2019-24, focused more on privatization, financial-sector reforms and judicial changes.
The third edition places greater emphasis on reducing the cost of doing business, improving trade facilitation and addressing structural constraints affecting manufacturing and employment.
D’Rozario clarified that the Scorecard represents recommendations from economic experts rather than an official list of government commitments. “It’s important to note that the Scorecard is an expert wish list, and not the Modi government’s announced agenda. We built it by surveying economists and then trimming it down to 30 big ticket items via a murder board. Some may say these reforms are too difficult or idealistic, but they aren’t. Look at civil nuclear power. Opening it up was considered impossible a few years ago, and it has now happened.”
Three reforms completed, structural agenda remains pending
Assessing progress under Scorecard 3.0, D’Rozario identified three completed recommendations but said the government’s broader structural reform agenda had yet to advance.
“Three of the 30 reforms are complete for our current Scorecard: rationalizing GST slabs, opening nuclear energy to private investment through the SHANTI Act, and Jan Vishwas 2.0. There are 26 reforms that haven’t started yet. The Modi government is strong and riding a wave of recent state election wins in West Bengal, for instance. This has added new momentum to the government’s popularity. It must seize this opportunity in favor of reforms! The big structural reforms remain stalled: land acquisition, agriculture laws, labor flexibility, privatization, and the remaining FDI openings. We realize that these are big tickets items. Each of our Scorecard also lists how difficult a reform is, from Low to Medium to High. Many of the reforms passed in Scorecard 3.0 are Medium to High – which is impressive!”
READ: Economy will sacrifice elections (September 15, 2026)
The three completed reforms relate to taxation, nuclear energy and the decriminalization of certain business-related offenses. The SHANTI Act opened the nuclear energy sector to private investment, while Jan Vishwas 2.0 forms part of the government’s effort to reduce the criminalization of business-related regulatory violations.
However, D’Rozario identified land acquisition, agricultural reform and labor flexibility as areas where the government has yet to make progress. He also argued that the government should use its political position to advance reforms that have historically faced resistance.
The CSIS analysis by Rossow similarly identified privatization, modernization of the Electricity Act, further relaxation of labor regulations and more efficient resolution of business-related legal cases as unfinished parts of the domestic reform agenda.
Employment generation depends on land and agricultural reforms
India’s economic growth has remained relatively strong, but employment generation, private investment and the quality of growth remain important challenges. D’Rozario said the reforms most closely connected to these issues were among those that had not advanced.
“They are aimed squarely at those problems, but the reforms that matter most for jobs and investment are the ones that haven’t moved. Easier land acquisition and agriculture reform would do the most for employment. The reforms completed so far, GST and decriminalization, lower the cost of compliance. That helps, but it doesn’t change much on its own. In our view, there are many reforms in our Scorecard that can be done without parliament: the government can do much more via non-legislative mechanisms.”
According to D’Rozario, simplifying GST compliance and decriminalizing certain business offenses can reduce the administrative burden on companies. However, such measures alone cannot address the structural obstacles that affect employment and investment.
Agricultural reforms also have implications beyond the farm sector, particularly for rural employment, supply chains and the development of agro-processing industries. D’Rozario argued that the government could advance several recommendations through administrative and regulatory measures without waiting for new legislation from Parliament.
This approach could allow the government to address business-related bottlenecks while pursuing more complicated legislative reforms.
Trade policy emerges as an area of progress
Trade policy is one area where D’Rozario sees comparatively greater movement during Modi’s third term.
India has continued negotiating trade agreements with major economic partners, while recent Union Budgets have reduced more tariff lines than they have increased. The government has also relied less heavily on non-tariff measures such as Quality Control Orders (QCOs) and local manufacturing requirements, he said.
“Trade is the strongest area of this term. India is pursuing trade agreements focused on cutting tariffs with key partners, recent budgets have cut more tariff lines than they’ve raised, and the government is relying less on Quality Control Orders and local manufacturing rules.The gaps are in day-to-day trade friction: inverted duty structures, which tax inputs more than finished goods, a single portal for trade documents, and dedicated customs lanes for e-commerce exports are all still not started.”
The CSIS analysis also identified trade policy as the strongest area of progress during Modi’s third term. However, D’Rozario said several operational barriers continue to affect Indian businesses seeking to expand their exports.
Read: Economic Dystopia and Biology of true value creation (August 23, 2026)
One such issue is the inverted duty structure, in which imported raw materials or intermediate goods face higher customs duties than finished products. This can raise manufacturing costs and make domestic producers less competitive.
The absence of a single portal for trade-related documentation also creates administrative challenges for exporters.
Dedicated customs clearance lanes for e-commerce exports could help reduce processing delays, particularly for smaller businesses that depend on faster shipping to reach international customers.
These measures are relevant to India’s ambition to expand manufacturing and increase its participation in global supply chains.
FDI liberalization among four key priorities before 2029
D’Rozario identified four major areas that the government should prioritize before the end of its current term in 2029: FDI liberalization, land acquisition, labor flexibility and correcting inverted duty structures.
His first recommendation is to restart the process of opening more sectors to foreign investment. “Restart FDI liberalization. Retail, e-commerce, and legal services are still restricted.” The recommendation comes amid concerns over the pace of new foreign investment reforms.
Rossow’s CSIS analysis noted that the Modi government had undertaken only one FDI reform during the first two and a half years of its third term: an amendment to the Insurance Act increasing the maximum foreign investment limit in insurance companies from 74% to 100%.
The report compared this with 37 FDI reforms during Modi’s first term and 12 during his second term. It also noted that more than 30 sectors continued to have some form of FDI limitation.
D’Rozario’s second priority is streamlining land acquisition. “Streamline land acquisition. Without land, manufacturing and infrastructure can’t scale.” His third recommendation concerns labor regulations, particularly the threshold for companies seeking government permission before laying off workers. “Make labor rules more flexible. Raise the limit for laying off workers without government permission to 1,000, so firms aren’t penalized for growing.” The proposal seeks to give businesses greater flexibility in workforce management as they expand operations. His fourth priority is correcting inverted duty structures to improve manufacturing competitiveness and help Indian companies benefit more effectively from trade agreements. “Fix inverted duty structures. This is a direct boost to manufacturing competitiveness and to getting the most out of trade agreements.”
Non-legislative reforms could improve investment and business conditions
Beyond the four priorities, D’Rozario argued that the government could introduce additional economic reforms through administrative and regulatory decisions.
He referred to an earlier article he had written for India Today, titled “Economic reforms do not always need laws, and Budget 2026 can show the way,” which outlined measures that could be implemented without extensive legislative changes.
One proposal concerns increasing the investment ceiling for foreign institutional investors in Indian companies.
“Raise ceiling on foreign institutional investment in Indian companies: The long-standing 10 percent limit on single institutional investors is a major hindrance for investment in high-growth Indian companies. The Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) raising this threshold, even to merely 20 percent, will unlock significant liquidity for listed Indian companies.”
The proposal focuses on allowing institutional investors to hold larger stakes in listed Indian companies. According to D’Rozario, increasing the threshold from 10% to 20% could provide additional liquidity and expand investment opportunities for high-growth businesses.
Another recommendation addresses India’s judicial backlog and its implications for commercial activity.
“Introduce an umbrella Online Dispute Resolution (ODR) system which includes a national ODR platform: India currently has over 50 million pending cases across various courts, many related to business and commercial disputes. With about 15 judges per million people, it could take hundreds of years to clear the existing backlog of cases across the country. Introducing Online Dispute Resolution will allow for speedier resolution of cases and reduce the burden for India’s overstretched judicial infrastructure.”
D’Rozario proposed a national ODR platform to provide an alternative mechanism for resolving disputes, particularly commercial and business-related cases.
A digital dispute-resolution framework could help reduce the burden on conventional courts and allow businesses to resolve certain disputes without lengthy litigation. His third proposal focuses on improving customs procedures for e-commerce exporters.
READ: CSIS launches India Economic Reform Scorecard (November 17, 2015)
“Establish dedicated customs clearance lanes for e-commerce exports: E-commerce exports in India amount to between $4-5 billion as of 2023 and form a small percentage of total merchandise exports. Customs clearance for exports in India can be a long process, including processing of shipping bill, inspection of goods at docks, system appraisal of shipping bills, customs examination of export cargo, and loading. Easing e-commerce exports is important to achieve the government’s plan of increasing merchandise exports to $1 trillion by 2030. To increase e-commerce exports, establishing dedicated customs clearance lanes for e-commerce exports can be an accelerant.”
State-level reforms remain a major challenge
The CSIS analysis by Rossow also highlighted the importance of state governments in implementing economic reforms. Rossow also called for the revival of initiatives such as model policies for states and the Business Reform Action Plan (BRAP), which was designed to encourage and assess improvements in state-level business regulations.
The CSIS analysis noted that India reported 7.8% economic growth in the first quarter of the fiscal year. FDI inflows reached $70 billion between September 2025 and October 2026, a 24% increase from the previous year. Goods exports rose 9% year over year, while services exports increased 10%.
Despite these indicators, Rossow argued that strong economic performance should not reduce the urgency of structural reforms.
For D’Rozario, the unfinished recommendations in Scorecard 3.0 point to the need for a broader approach that combines legislative changes with administrative improvements.
With the current government’s term running until 2029, the remaining period will determine how many of the proposed reforms move from recommendations to implementation, particularly in areas affecting foreign investment, manufacturing, trade and employment.


